GlamRock.com Forum » GLAM Music Forum

GLAM METAL OR NOT? THE ETERNAL DEBATES...

(29 posts)
  • Started 1 year ago by SIXX-Again
  • Latest reply from HEAVYMETALrocks

  1. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    "Musically, glam metal uses traditional hard rock and heavy metal songs, incorporating elements of punk rock, while adding pop-influenced catchy hooks and guitar riffs. Like other heavy metal songs of the 1980s, they often feature shred guitar solos. Aesthetically glam metal draws heavily on the glam rock or glitter rock of the 1970s, often with very long backcombed hair, use of make-up, gaudy clothing and accessories (chiefly consisting of tight denim or leather jeans, spandex, and headbands)."

    That's how Wikipedia characterizes glam metal. And I think it's pretty dead on. It describes in one way or another all the bands we celebrate and pan on GlamRock.com. From Aerosmith to Winger. From old bands like the Crue, to new bands like Crashdiet. Musically and aesthetically.

    Bands like KISS, Motley Crue, Poison, Ratt, Cinderella, Warrant, Britny Fox & Stryper are, without a doubt, glam metal.

    But what about bands like Whitesnake, Great White, Tesla, Queensryche, Van Halen, Aerosmith, Scorpions, Skid Row, Def Leppard, Ozzy...and of course, Guns N Roses?

    They all followed the glam metal standards in some way or another: Arena anthems, power ballads, spandex, etc. All of them.

    I've heard/read/had endless debates(80s to present day)about these bands being Glam metal or not.

    **Great White, Whitesnake & Tesla. Are they glam metal or blues rock?

    **Queensryche. Are they glam metal or progressive metal?

    **Ozzy, Aerosmith, Van Halen & Scorpions. Aren't they just classic rockers whose sounds evolved with the times?

    **Guns N Roses. Always described as being "grittier and rawer" than all the Glam bands, and therefore not glam. Compared to Poison & Warrant, absolutely. But remember, their "grittier" music includes "Sweet Child O Mine", "November Rain", "Mr. Brownstone", and "Welcome To The Jungle". Pretty mainstream tunes. Even in the late 80s/90s when they were new. So what do we do? We create another sub-genre and call them "sleaze".

    I say, why split hairs? The 80s gave us two types of metal: Thrash metal and Glam(Pop) metal. All the other styles are just sub-genres of these two types of metal.

    So where do you stand in the eternal debates? Pick one band, or pick them all, or cite one not listed, and tell us if you think they're Glam or Not. Why or why not?

    **WHITESNAKE
    **GREAT WHITE
    **TESLA
    **QUEENSRYCHE
    **DEF LEPPARD
    **SKID ROW
    **L.A.GUNS
    **VAN HALEN
    **AEROSMITH
    **SCORPIONS
    **OZZY
    **GUNS N ROSES

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  2. Retroman

    offline
    Moderator

    PostCount: 778

    SIXX-Again Cheers man for creating this topic.

    "I say, why split hairs? The 80s gave us two types of metal: Thrash metal and Glam(Pop) metal. All the other styles are just sub-genres of these two types of metal.
    So where do you stand in the eternal debates? Pick one band, or pick them all, or cite one not listed, and tell us if you think they're Glam or Not. Why or why not?" - SIXX-Again

    In reality there are no subgenres of 'Thrash Metal' or 'Glam Metal'. The easiest explanation is to show the hierarchical structure (using indentation) of the rock music genre. Alternative names of subgenres are seperated by a slash. Please note that I have only included the subgenres of interest, i.e. those that cover the 70s or 80s:

    ROCK
    ....ALTERNATIVE ROCK / ALTERNATIVE MUSIC
    ........GOTHIC ROCK / GOTH ROCK / GOTH
    ........GRUNGE
    ....BLUES ROCK
    ....FUNK ROCK
    ........FUNK METAL
    ....GLAM ROCK / GLITTER ROCK
    ....HEAVY METAL / HARD ROCK / HEAVY ROCK
    ........EXTREME METAL
    ............BLACK METAL
    ............DEATH METAL
    ................MELODIC DEATH METAL
    ............GRINDCORE
    ............THRASH METAL
    ........GLAM METAL / HAIR METAL / POP METAL / SLEAZE METAL
    ........NU METAL / AGGRO METAL
    ........POWER METAL
    ........PROGRESSIVE METAL
    ........SPEED METAL
    ....PROGRESSIVE ROCK / PROG ROCK
    ....PSYCHEDELIC ROCK
    ....PUNK ROCK
    ........GLAM PUNK
    ........HARDCORE PUNK / HARDCORE

    Many bands change musical direction during the course of their career so it is usually appropriate to never class them as one specific genre.

    Here are some notes on how the important subgenres of rock came about. The year is placed after each band to construct the timeline of formation.

    BLUES ROCK

    Blues rock is an important subgenre of rock that encompasses many recording artists. The Rolling Stones 1962, The Animals 1962 and Eric Clapton 1962 were among the first to develop the blues rock sound. Other bands include Fleetwood Mac 1967, ZZ Top 1969, Gary Moore 1969 and The Black Crowes 1989. Blues rock influenced the style of many glam metal and hard rock bands of the 80s and early 90s.

    HEAVY METAL / HARD ROCK / HEAVY ROCK

    The roots of this subgenre can be traced to the 1960s and include blues, garage and psychedelic rock. Black Sabbath 1968, Deep Purple 1968 and Judas Priest 1968 were the first pioneers of heavy metal followed by the New Wave Of British Heavy Metal including Iron Maiden 1975. Heavy metal or simply 'metal' has many subgenres to categorise the results of the fusions between the multitude of musical styles it has adopted. Many bands fall into this classification including Led Zeppelin 1968, Aerosmith 1970, KISS 1973, AC/DC 1973, Van Halen 1972, Def Leppard 1977, Whitesnake 1977, Guns N'Roses 1985, Skid Row 1986 and Tesla 1984. Material produced before the sub-dividing of the metal genre is usually classed as 'classic metal' or 'traditional metal'.

    GLAM ROCK / GLITTER ROCK

    The roots of this subgenre date back to the early 1970s and include Gary Glitter 1960, Mud 1966, Slade 1966, Sweet 1968 and Roxy Music 1971. It must be noted that David Bowie's connection with this era is short lived during the use of his alter ego 'Ziggy Stardust'.

    PUNK ROCK

    The New Yorks Dolls 1971 are seen as the initiators of the Punk era. Bands include The Ramones 1974, The Stranglers 1974, The Sex Pistols 1975, The Runaways 1975 and The Clash 1976.

    GOTHIC ROCK / GOTH ROCK / GOTH

    The Cure 1976 are one of the early pioneers of this darker form of rock. Other bands include Siouxsie and the Banshees 1976, The Sisters Of Mercy 1980, The Cult 1983, Fields of the Nephilim 1984 and All About Eve 1984.

    HARDCORE PUNK / HARDCORE

    The pioneers of this subgenre were the The Dead Kennedys 1978. Bands include Discharge 1977, The Exploited 1979 and Agnostic Front 1980. Hardcore punk influenced the thrash metal scene. The phrase 'Mosh' comes from the way hardcore punk fans acted on the dance floor.

    GLAM METAL / HAIR METAL / POP METAL / SLEAZE METAL

    Glam metal has many names, all encompassing the same set of bands. Ratt 1976 and Motley Crue 1981 were among the first to pioneer the style of music that would later be classed as 'glam metal'. Other bands include Europe 1979, Kix 1978, Poison 1983, Warrant 1984 and Cinderella 1983 and many more...

    SPEED METAL

    Pioneered by Motorhead 1975, Judas Priest 1968 and the NWOBHM, you will find elements of speed metal in many thrash bands including Slayer 1981 and Anthrax 1981.

    THRASH METAL

    Influenced by the heavy metal band Venom 1979, many of the early thrash bands came from the San Francisco Bay Area and included Exodus 1980, Overkill 1980, Metallica 1981, Slayer 1981 and Anthrax 1981. Megadeth came a little later in 1983. Thrash metal had commercial success in the 80s and well into the 90s. It is claimed that Metallica initially played thrash metal to annoy the glam metal fans of the Sunset Strip.

    BLACK METAL

    The heavy metal band Venom 1979 helped influence this subgenre, which took its name from their second studio album "Black Metal" 1982. The first wave of bands included Bathory 1983 , Hellhammer 1982, Celtic Frost 1984 and Mayhem 1984. The second wave came in the late 80s and early 90s and mainly consisted of Norwegian bands including Darkthrone 1987, Burzum 1991, Emperor 1991, Immortal 1989 and Cradle of Filth 1991. Black metal is one of the most brutal sounding forms of the heavy metal genre. Cradle Of Filth helped promote the existence of black metal during the 90s, being very popular with teenie 'goth' girls.

    DEATH METAL

    The initial pioneer of death metal was the band Death 1983. Other bands include Morbid Angel 1984, Cannibal Corpse 1988, Carcass 1985, Obituary 1985, Sepultura 1984, At The Gates 1990, Dissection 1989, Dark Tranquillity 1989 and Fear Factory 1989. Death metal has grown to be one of the biggest forms of heavy metal and has spawned many of its own subgenres.

    GRINDCORE

    Napalm Death 1981 are credited as the initial innovators of this brutal subgenre of heavy metal, taking influences from hardcore punk. Bands include Extreme Noise Terror 1985, Terrorizer 1986 and Autopsy 1987.

    FUNK METAL

    Faith No More 1981 were one of the first bands to invent this subgenre. Bands include Bang Tango 1987, Extreme 1985, Electric Boys 1988, Living Colour 1984 and Mordred 1984.

    The genres defined above were all legitimate, unique and had fan bases during the 70s and 80s.

    To conclude, using the rock genre tree - all of the bands in the following list can be classed as either rock, heavy metal, hard rock or heavy rock. Glam metal is used to classify a specific range of 80s bands that roughly contain the definition you initially quoted from wikipedia. It is hard to find a band that is pure 'glam metal' as the whole genre was named in retrospect, plus many bands changed direction or were simply part of the glam metal scene in passing, take Aerosmith for example.

    **WHITESNAKE
    **GREAT WHITE
    **TESLA
    **QUEENSRYCHE
    **DEF LEPPARD
    **SKID ROW
    **L.A.GUNS
    **VAN HALEN
    **AEROSMITH
    **SCORPIONS
    **OZZY
    **GUNS N ROSES

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  3. Retroman

    offline
    Moderator

    PostCount: 778

    **UPDATE**

    Here are some bands taken from my iTunes digital DJ collection that I started back in 2003. I have listed them in the genres that I initially defined and work with. I filed glam metal bands under AOR (Adult Oriented Rock). I have found that is not convenient to 'spit hairs' when organising my music collection.

    The following list is personal and may not reflect the actual true classification:

    AOR:

    Alannah Myles
    Babylon AD
    Badlands
    Beau Nasty
    Big House
    Black Crowes
    Blue Blud
    Bonfire
    Bonham
    Brighton Rock
    Britny Fox
    Bulletboys
    Child's Play
    Chrissy Steele
    Cinderella
    Cold Sweat
    Danger Danger
    Dare
    Doro
    Electric Boys
    Enuff Z'Nuff
    Every Mother's Nightmare
    Extreme
    Faster Pussycat
    Fate
    Femme Fatale
    Firehouse
    FM
    Giant
    Great White
    Gypsy Rose
    House Of Lords
    Howe 2
    Hurricane
    Icon
    Jagged Edge
    Johnny Crash
    Kik Tracee
    Kingdom Come
    Kix
    L.A. Guns
    Leatherwolf
    Lee Aaron
    Lion
    Lita Ford
    Little Angels
    Lynch Mob
    Michael Monroe
    Motley Crue
    Mr. Big
    MSG
    National Velvet
    Poison
    Precious Metal
    Pretty Boy Floyd
    Princess Pang
    Queensryche
    Ratt
    Robin Beck
    Romeo's Daughter
    Roxx Gang
    Saraya
    Shark Island
    Skid Row
    Slaughter
    Sleeze Beez
    Slik Toxik
    Smashed Gladys
    Sons Of Angels
    Spread Eagle
    Steelheart
    Sweet F.A.
    Tesla
    Thunder
    Tigertailz
    TNT
    Tora Tora
    Trixter
    Tuff
    Tyketto
    Vain
    Vamp
    Vinnie Vincent Invasion
    Vixen
    Warrant
    White Lion
    Winger
    Wolfsbane
    XYZ
    Yngwie Malmsteen

    ROCK:

    Aerosmith
    Alice Cooper
    Baby Animals
    Bangles
    Belinda Carlisle
    Berlin
    Billy Idol
    Bon Jovi
    Boston
    Bryan Adams
    Cars
    Cher
    Chicago
    Cult
    Damn Yankees
    David Lee Roth
    Deep Purple
    Def Leppard
    Dio
    Dire Straits
    Doors
    Europe
    Fleetwood Mac
    Genesis
    Guns N'Roses
    Heart
    INXS
    Joan Jett And The Blackhearts
    Journey
    KISS
    Led Zeppelin
    Living Colour
    Marillion
    Meat Loaf
    Pat Benatar
    Pink Floyd
    Police
    Pretenders
    Queen
    Quireboys
    REM
    Roxette
    Roxy Music
    Runaways
    Rush
    Sad Cafe
    Saxon
    Scorpions
    Simple Minds
    Slade
    Status Quo
    Stevie Nicks
    Styx
    Survivor
    Sweet
    T'pau
    T. Rex
    Twisted Sister
    U2
    Ugly Kid Joe
    Van Halen
    Whitesnake
    ZZ Top

    METAL:

    AC/DC
    Acid Reign
    Almighty
    Annihilator
    Anthrax
    At The Gates
    Black Sabbath
    Blaze
    Bruce Dickinson
    Carcass
    Celtic Frost
    Coal Chamber
    Cradle Of Filth
    Dark Funeral
    Dark Tranquillity
    Darkness
    Death
    Death Angel
    Dimmu Borgir
    Dissection
    Disturbed
    Emperor
    Evanescence
    Fear Factory
    Grip Inc.
    Helloween
    Immortal
    Incubus
    Iron Maiden
    Judas Priest
    Korn
    Kreator
    Lacuna Coil
    Linkin Park
    Lostprophets
    Machine Head
    Mayhem
    Megadeth
    Metallica
    Ministry
    Morbid Angel
    Mordred
    Motorhead
    Napalm Death
    Onslaught
    Overkill
    Ozzy Osbourne
    Pantera
    Papa Roach
    Phantom Blue
    Rob Zombie
    Sanctuary
    Sepultura
    Slayer
    Slipknot
    Soulfly
    Strapping Young Lad
    System Of A Down
    Testament
    Warlock
    Wasp
    White Zombie
    Whithin Temptation

    ALTERNATIVE:

    30 Seconds To Mars
    Alanis Morissette
    Alice In Chains
    Avril Lavigne
    Biffy Clyro
    Bullet For My Valentine
    Cardigans
    Coldplay
    Depeche Mode
    Editors
    Elbow
    Electric Six
    Enter Shikari
    Faith No More
    Feeder
    Foo Fighters
    Franz Ferdinand
    Fratellis
    Funeral For A Friend
    Garbage
    Goldfrapp
    Green Day
    Gun
    Hole
    Joy Division
    Kaiser Chiefs
    Kasabian
    Kelly Clarkson
    Kill Hannah
    Killers
    Kings Of Leon
    Kooks
    L7
    Lenny Kravitz
    Levellers
    Libertines
    Lily Allen
    Limp Bizkit
    Lostprophets
    Love/Hate
    Lucie Silvas
    Manic Street Preachers
    Marilyn Manson
    Metro Station
    Mind Funk
    Mission
    Muse
    My Chemical Romance
    New Order
    Nickelback
    Nine Inch Nails
    Nirvana
    Oasis
    Offspring
    Paramore
    Pendulum
    Pink
    Placebo
    Pleasure Bombs
    Prodigy
    Puddle Of Mud
    Pulp
    Radiohead
    Rage Against The Machine
    Razorlight
    Red Hot Chili Peppers
    Skunk Anansie
    Snow Patrol
    Soundgraden
    Staind
    Stefy
    Stereophonics
    Terrorvision
    Therapy
    Ting Tings
    Tori Amos
    Veronicas
    Zutons

    GOTH:

    All About Eve
    Anathema
    Cure
    Fields Of The Nephilim
    Gary Numan
    Killing Joke
    London After Midnight
    Moonspell
    My Dying Bride
    Opeth
    Paradise Lost
    Siouxsie And The Banshees
    Sisters Of Mercy
    Switchblade Symphony
    Type O Negative

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  4. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    i believe everything that was said in the beginning about the look...but i truely believe the lyrics and the music itself play just as big a role in making glam what glam truely is

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  5. RockLibertyWarrior

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 715

    For lack of a better term I don't use glam when in a conversation with people about music of the 80's. I use hair metal which encompasses all bands from Poison and Crue to Metallica to Slayer. Some of the bands above you listed didn't wear make up or even some of the clothes associated with glam. However in sound they are glam metal! Really Rhythm and Bluesy based music for the most part but again it seems Slayer and Queensryche threw out the blues book some I am a bit confused but I still call it hair metal!

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  6. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    Retroman! :D Thorough as usual! Cheers to you, man!

    As far as your personal list/classification goes I agree with a lot of it...Some is odd to me, though.

    **Never thought of Kelly Clarkson or Kings of Leon & Nickelback as anything but Pop and Pop Rock respectively. Definitely not Alternative!

    **Never found Incubus to be Metal in any way. I would call them Alternative. Same with INXS under Rock, again, they're Alternative to me.

    **I've also(personally)never considered David Bowie, Roxy Music, or Japan Glam Rock, even though I always see them classified as such. I've always thought of Bowie as an originator of Alternative. And Roxy Music & Japan as originators of New Wave/Synth Rock.

    But, hey, everybody's has their own opinion about music and how to classify it. And it's all good. It inspires fun, yet spirited & passionate debates(right, Brooklynace? :lol: ...That's an inside joke...).

    I am curious, Retroman, what do you consider Tesla? On your two posts you have them classified as different things. Post #1 as Heavy Metal/Hard Rock/Heavy Rock, and in Post #2 you have them as AOR which you said was your Glam metal bands list. I'm assuming it's the classification on Post #2?

    I'd like to also acknowledge metalrulesall's comment about the lyrics of the songs playing a big role... This is another perfect example of the hypocritical opinions that GNR was not glam, while Motley Crue is. Each band had a 'love' song about killing their girl("Used To Love Her" from Guns, and "You're All I Need" from Crue.). Both had songs about addictions("Mr. Brownstone" from Guns, "Dancing On Glass" from Crue), etc, etc.

    So I ask again, why is GNR not Glam Metal, but Motley Crue is? :?

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  7. RockLibertyWarrior

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 715

    I have always considered GNR glam, when they started they had the whole make up thing going on but ditched it later. I guess to me glam music is just sleazy sounding and GNR had that sleazy sound, outrageousness, and biggness that just screamed GLAM! Incubus is not metal, their gayer than gay but again that is just my opinion. :lol:

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  8. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    GNR arent glam because there lryics were more punk-ish oriented then they were glam oriented plus, i dont think they dressed at asll glam...they dressed really punky and even grungry alot of the time...thats my opinion and im sticking to it

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  9. Retroman

    offline
    Moderator

    PostCount: 778

    First of all, I only deal with thirteen genres in total to class my music collection as the whole process is a complete nightmare to start with so why make it harder! iTunes curently states that I have 4909 artists and 16422 items, 54.5 days playing time. I've got better things to do with my time than nit pick over what genre each artist or song should be, although Kings Of Leon, Nickelback and Alannah Myles are going to be re-classified to 'rock' because of this thread :)

    I use the following thirteen genres as a working system for both DJing and personal use, grouping specific artists together for quick retrieval:

    ALTERNATIVE
    AOR
    CYBER
    DANCE
    DISCO
    ELECTRONIC
    GOTH
    METAL
    POP
    PUNK
    ROCK
    URBAN
    XMAS

    Indie pop/rock and alternative/rock/metal screw up my whole system so I just throw tracks of that nature into the alternative section. I normally class an artist based on the tonal qualities i.e. guitar sound, playing style, vocals etc. I don't usually file artists under multiple genres unless I really have to. Anyway, here are my answers to some of SIXX-Again's previous questions:

    I classed Kelly Clarkson as alternative because of the guitars in 'Since U Been Gone':

    Kelly's a bit heavier than your average pop artist and at least she has a band. See the following two examples of recent pop music:

    As for INXS, I class them as 'rock' based on the 1987 album 'Kick':

    Incubus get classed as 'metal' because of the song "A Certain Shade Of Green". The guitar riffin' says 'metal' to me but who cares about 'em anyway:

    Roxy Music have had many styles over the years, I have them filed under rock, pop & disco. They are too complicated to discuss right now:

    TESLA:

    I filed Tesla under AOR seven years ago but the official classification on their website is 'Hard Rock' hence the contradiction on my two previous posts. I think it is easy to say that Tesla were one of the more serious bands of the 80s/90s. They sang about real world issues rather than just sex & drugs... When they did sing about sex, drugs & rock n'roll, it had a certain elegance about it. I don't associate Tesla with the 'badboy' image that Motley Crue and Skid Row promoted.

    Tesla's music is based on blues, their back catalog has musical similarities to many 80s/90s glam metal bands. The very fact that they existed as a rock band in the 80s meant that they had the whole 80s image and fashion thing going on; big hair and glammy clothes although the 'glam metal' image was toned down on stage and in their music videos. Tesla certainly didn't wear make-up as their music came before image. The band were one of the first to release a live acoustic album following the 'unplugged' trend fueled by MTV in the late 80s. Tesla continued into the 90s writing 'glam metal' numbers, 'Edison's Medicine' for example. Tesla actually claim that they were never 'glam' but looking at their history and the bands they toured with it is easy to see why they were classified that way.

    The following videos show Tesla back in the 80s and early 90s. Looks/sounds like glam metal to me... I can also quite happily class them as 'hard rock' or 'hair metal' (explanation at the bottom of this post):

    To sum things up, I find that my definition of 'glam metal' doesn't necessarily mean the band needs to wear make-up. For me, it's the hair, the clothes, the music and the attitude. Confusingly, many of the bands on GlamRock.com can be placed into more than one of the following genres: 'hard rock', 'glam metal', 'glam rock' and 'hair metal' etc. There is no definitive answer (as yet). The problem arises when you try to classify a band into one specific genre and assume that all other similar bands are of the same vein. The truth is they are all 'rock' as opposed to 'rap', 'dance', 'classical' etc... Ask the bands yourself and you will probably get a completely different opinion from each of them.

    I'm gonna leave other bands including Guns N'Roses for another time...

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  10. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    Point taken on everything but Kelly Clarkson, Retroman. :D Sorry, but that's a giant leap for me to see her as anything but a manufactured pop star...literally.

    INXS is one of my top ten favorite bands of all time, and based on the Kick album they did rock it up. They've pretty much always done that, though. They rocked it up with "Don't Change"(from Shabooh Shoobah), and then synthed it up for "Johnson's Aeroplane"(from The Swing, and funked it up with "Need You Tonight"(from Kick)...They are amazing! And their constant shift in style puts them in the alternative category for me.

    I'm with you 100% on glam metal bands not requiring make-up, spandex, and sex, drug and Rock n Roll lyrics to be Glam Metal! For every "bad boy" band like Guns and Crue, there was a "nice boy" band like Bon Jovi and Stryper. For every make-up wearing band like Poison & Ratt, there was a no-nonsense band like Skid Row & Tesla...

    As I said it's the eternal debate...and I love it! :D

    Look forward to more perspectives on specific bands! Especially Retroman's stance on Guns N' Roses. :wink:

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  11. ironmanben

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 73

    Ozzy's earlier stuff seems pretty Glam Metal, like Flying High Again,etc. They had the big hair and the lyrics about sex and drugs enough to make them glam. But after Zakk Wylde, he startd to move out of that.

    Guns n' Roses is definitely Glam Metal, although there are many more genres of Rock they could fall under. Lyrical themes and visual appearance both make them glam.

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  12. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    For me Ozzy only sounded Glam during the Jake E. Lee era(and what an era that was!!).

    PRE-LEE: The song "Crazy Train" has the glam metal feel to it as well. But all the other tunes from Blizzard of Ozz and Diary of a Madman sounded like standard heavy metal.

    POST-LEE: And once Zakk Wylde teamed up with Ozzy, the music returned to standard metal.

    So '83-'87 Ozzy: Definitely Glam(who can ever forget the outfit he wore in the "Shot in the Dark" video! :lol: ).

    All surrounding years: Not Glam; standard heavy metal.

    At least to me...

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  13. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    i agree with you 100%

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  14. Salem

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 52

    All these different tags for metal are ridiculous. It doesn't need to be that complicated.
    I hung out with a huge group of devoted headbangers back in the days when metal was at its peak and no one ever used terms like AOR, Alternative, Progressive Metal or Melodic Metal.
    It was simple, you were either a "scumbag" or a "poser". This meant that bands that were considered thrash, speed, death or black metal instantly fell into the "scumbag" category. If you listened to bands that were labeled glam, hard rock, sleaze or hair metal you were a "poser".
    There were exceptions to the rule that made it perfectly ok for both a poser and a scumbag to like certain bands ( Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, WASP, Dio, Motorhead, Ozzy).

    I was always a "poser" and had plenty of fellow poser friends but I had good friends who were scumbags too. They'd make fun of me for listening to guys in eyeliner & hairspray wearing tights and I'd make fun of them for listening to euro guys running around the woods at night with swords wearing Gene Simmons make-up pretending to be really evil.

    It didn't matter if you were into glam or into thrash, it was all about METAL, and thats what we should be talking about here instead of Kelly Clarkson and the fuckin' Sugababes.

    To answer the earlier question, yes Guns n Roses were glam and if you liked them you were a poser.

    If you didnt fall into either the "scumbag" or "poser" category then you were just a "tryhard" and your existence meant nothing.

    http://www.myspace.com/trashbrat Hated By Millions...Loved By All.
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  15. Retroman

    offline
    Moderator

    PostCount: 778

    Like it or not, these 'ridiculous' tags exist for a reason and are here to stay. We need these tags/subgenres to clearly separate the many different types of artists and bands encounted over the years. I would say that it is not complicated, if you don't understand or care for a certain subgenre then you probably don't need to... you can simply step up a level and use a higher definition such as 'METAL' or 'ROCK' but that takes things back to square one again for example, if a bunch of christian metal fans described their taste as purely 'METAL' then confusion could arise when they tried to mingle with a group of black metallers, who also decided to described their taste as purely 'METAL' :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:

    I do agree that back in the old days (the 80s) it was just about 'METAL' and separation was mainly 'glam' vs 'thrash'. The metalheads or 'rockers' as they were known in my town liked anything from Bon Jovi to Metallica mixing happily together. It was only later on in the 90s when I travelled from city to city in the UK that I came across genre snobs... sure we hung together in the same clubs and at parties but the subgenres of rock/metal seperated us, I remember the goths and extreme metallers being the worst.

    As for Kelly Clarkson being debated on this thread, it's a classic case of two people having opposing views when generic examples are used to define a point. I still say her musical sound can be described as 'alternative rock' hehe :) I think the trouble with Kelly is the simple fact that many metalheads don't like her so her very mention screws the whole debate up! I personally try to keep an academic perspective when it comes to classification. Ironically, just like SIXX-Again and myself discussed Kelly Clarkson from her appearance in my long list of example artists, Salem brought her into his argument thus she got mentioned yet again to prove another point, now I've had to mention her, arrrh will this ever end? Enough said, lets continue this thread on the original topic of the eternal glam metal debate...

    When it comes to Gun N'Roses, I can't bring myself to class them as 'glam' although they look that way. I would say 'hard rock' if I was pushed to define them. Like I said in a previous post, ask the band members if you wanna find out what style they are? I have provided a useful artical including Slash commenting on GNR's image: "We are not Glam shit or anything else. We are just Guns N'Roses."

    The following scan is from a May '89 editon of UK rock magazine, RAW. The influences are very interesting, somehow the Pet Shop Boys and George Michael get mentioned! This topic just gets weirder:

    GNR

    As for being a 'poser' or a 'scumbag'? I liked GNR, Iron Maiden and Metallica, in fact I wanted my hair just like Slash when I was 15 and judging from the photograph above, he liked Metallica too... is Slash wearing that T-shirt to annoy 'posers' or is it just a coincidence?

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  16. Salem

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 52

    Well back then Slash was probably wearing that shirt cause someone gave it to him for free.
    Slash can pretend they weren't glam all he likes. I remember Motley, Skid Row & Poison saying the exact same thing.
    Look at the pic! His singer is standing there next to him in eyeliner, lipstick and hairspray. Yeah glad they weren't glam :roll: .

    http://www.myspace.com/trashbrat Hated By Millions...Loved By All.
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  17. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    That "poser" tag always annoyed the shit out of me! Especially when I heard bands like Metallica use it. They boast that their music is for "real" metal fans. :roll: And that glam fans were just following a trend. :roll:

    But I guarantee you're more likely to see someone in a Metallica shirt at a Poison concert, than someone in a Poison shirt at a Metallica concert! Why? Because glam rockers don't give a shit if you like thrash or glam -- it's what ever floats your boat. You know...freedom.

    However that freedom doesn't seem to exist among thrash fans. Go to a Slayer show wearing a Cinderella shirt: At best you get a roll of the eyes/shake of the head from others. Worst case scenario(and very likely), you get your ass kicked by some alpha-male thrasher screaming, "SLAAAAYERRR!!!" Why? Because they are the "posers", conforming to what is expected from a thrash fan. That is, hating anything Glam, and those who are real enough to say they love it! (We know they go home and listen to KISS' Destroyer. :wink: )

    **I respect Axl for admitting he likes the songs of George Michael and The Pet Shop Boys, just like I respect Retroman for including Kelly Clarkson and Coldplay in his personal collection. Hell, as I've said before on another thread, my Motley Crue tapes used to reside next to my Milli Vanilli tape. And one week in the 80s I would see Duran Duran in concert, and the following week it would be the Crue.

    Who has an opinion on Def Leppard?

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  18. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    i do ! haha...well first and formost, i fuckin love def leppard just about as much as i love the motherfuckin crue..theyve got excellent lyrics and musicianship..but as far as metal goes..i honestly think there earlier albums like on through the night(i.e the work they did b4 phil collin came along)was your typically glam rock even tho some songs did have metally riffs and shit but as for albums like pyromania and hysteria sound to me alot like pop in certain ways ya know ?...i think thats why alot of leppard fans consider them "pop metal" ...and thats my 2 cents

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  19. motleyguy

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 253

    "Who has an opinion on Def Leppard?" - SIXX-Again

    I believe that Def Leppard, whilst Steve Clark was in the band were definitely a glam band. Steve died in 1991 and so did glam as a mainstream movement. There timing of these two events should not be ignored.

    His replacement, Vivian Campbell came from a long hair band pedigree but like Bon Jovi, the band successfully adapted to their fans changing tastes however, I do feel at heart that Def Leppard always were and still are a hair band.

    Rock & roll over babe
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  20. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    who here likes helix anyone ?

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  21. Salem

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 52

    Not really a big Helix fan but loved seeing a teenage Traci Lords in their vid.

    http://www.myspace.com/trashbrat Hated By Millions...Loved By All.
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  22. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    theres too songs of theres i really like theres wild in the streets and heavy metal love....theres a few others too but not alot

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  23. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    I finally got the computer away from my kids long enough to give my two cents on Def Leppard...

    To me Leppard is similar to Aerosmith. They started as a hard rock band -- very '70s rock feel to the music. The first two albums, On Through The Night and High 'n' Dry are good rock albums...With one amazing glam song from the latter: "Bringin' On The Heartbreak". One of the all time greatest Power Ballads.

    Then when Pyromania hit in '83, after Mutt Lange fine tuned Leppard in the studio(for basically a YEAR!), they emerged as a lean mean Glam machine.

    They stayed glam/pop metal until(as motleyguy pointed out) Steve Clark died. I haven't quite been able to figure out what they've been since his death -- but I haven't liked any of it. :? They still sound great!...But only when they play the hits.

    Back to the Aerosmith similarity:

    **Hard Rock origins: Leppard had On Through The Night and High 'n' Dry. Aerosmith had Get Your Wings and Toys In The Attic.

    **The 80s Glam phase: Leppard had Pyromania and Hysteria. Aerosmith had Permanent Vacation and Pump

    **The 90s & current "throw this shit against the wall and see what sticks" phase: Leppard's got Adrenalize, Retro Active, Slang, X, etc. etc.(crap, crap & more crap :? ).

    Aerosmith is a little different here because they had Get A Grip before becoming erratic and giving us fluff like "Pink", "Jaded" & "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing" -- not to mention the endless kick in the nuts to the once classic rock tune "Walk This Way" turned classic Rap tune! (Come on, Aerosmith!! You guys used to rock that song on your own! Now it takes N'Sync, Britney Spears, Mary J. Blige & Nelly with Aerosmith!? COME ON!!)

    Actually Leppard has been whoring out their music and rock credibility like Aerosmith. Playing "Photograph" with Country/Pop princess Taylor Swift! And rocking(or rednecking - whatever you call it) with Tim McGraw on their own song "Nine Lives".

    It truly saddens me to see once great rock bands sell their rock n roll souls to the mainstream devil in order to stay "hip and current". Leppard, Aerosmith & Bon Jovi all became giants in the world of rock. They've all softened with old age and desires to remain BIG.

    Learn from Motley Crue, guys! Stick with what your fans love, and your fans will stick with you!

    That's my two cents(maybe ten cents). Perfect timing...Here come my kids...LATER. :wink:

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  24. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    Jæja ég held nokkuð óhætt að segja að Motley crue nokkurn veginn fundið Glam Metal

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  25. ironmanben

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 73

    Marilyn Manson is pretty glam, I think. He runs around wearing makeup and hairspray, and the musical hooks sound pretty hair-metal.

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  26. SIXX-Again

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 700

    I think Manson's 'attempting' to carry on the glam tradition of music & showmanship.

    Appearance-wise and stage show: I applaud that he's carrying on the Alice Cooper/KISS tradition of give the audience something to look at as well as listen to! However...I don't think anyone really wants to see his scrawny ass in bondage gear exposed on stage!

    Musically he hasn't impressed me at all! The only songs of his I remotely like are all covers of 80s tunes("Tainted Love", "Down In The Park", "Sweet Dreams".) His original & signature song, "Beautiful People" is, in my opinion...crap(no offense meant if your a fan, though).

    Then there's the off-stage Manson: Every interview I've seen, the guy seems like an asshole. No sign of a sense of humor about his antics. That's one thing he never learned from Alice Cooper & KISS: DON'T TAKE WHAT YOU DO TOO SERIOUSLY...Especially when you're in a glam rock band. :wink:

    Posted 1 year ago #  
  27. metalrulesall

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1782

    truer words was never spoken

    " into the flood again same old trip it was back then "
    Posted 1 year ago #  
  28. Rattrocker

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1

    **WHITESNAKE
    **GREAT WHITE
    **TESLA
    **QUEENSRYCHE
    **DEF LEPPARD: NWOBHM to glam metal to hard rock
    **SKID ROW: glam metal
    **L.A.GUNS: glam metal
    **VAN HALEN: hevay metal
    **AEROSMITH: hard rock
    **SCORPIONS: heavy metal
    **OZZY: heavy metal
    **GUNS N ROSES: glam metal
    **TESLA: heavy metal
    **GREAT WHITE: glam metal
    **WHITESNAKE: blues rock to glam metal to hard rock
    **QUEENSRŸCHE: progressive metal
    **SAXON: BWOBHM to glam metal back to NWOBHM

    Posted 12 months ago #  
  29. HEAVYMETALrocks

    offline
    Member

    PostCount: 1

    Anyone like Hanoi Rocks?

    Posted 9 months ago #  

Reply

You must log in to post.